Philosophical Reflections On Tal and Tabla

  CORVIN RUSSELL
 

Abstract:
An old saying in Indian music has it that "shruti [pitch] is the mother, and lay [time] is the father". This basic point about the equiprimordiality of metre and pitch seems obvious enough with respect not only to Indian music but also to all music. Yet this conception of rhythm and pitch as the fundamental material from which music is made has given rise to a parallel formula specific to Indian music: namely, that rag [melody] and tal [rhythm], while distinct entities, share in the constitution of Indian music as parallel, equally prior, and equally basic systems. This formula, while seeming prima facie little different from the old aphorism, is, I think, a subtle but significant error that has shaped a whole congeries of ideas about the nature and theoretical basis of Indian music. Primary among these ideas are those concerning the practice of tal, but also more specifically, as I will later show, ideas about drumming traditions. In particular, this belief has given rise to the feeling that both rag and tal should be explainable by similar theories and schemes, and should be musically expressible in similar ways.  

Download a pdf version of the full article. (156 K)  

 

 

 
  Graphic Design, Eric Parker and Assoc. Ltd., Copyright © 1997
  All text Copyright © respective authors, 1997. All Rights Reserved
  Original concept and inspiration, John Campana.
  All comments and contributions to ericp@pathcom.com

First Publication July 23, 1997 - This page updated October 8, 2004